Seminar On Aviation Safety Today
LAHORE (July 10 2009): The International Society of Air Safety Investigators (ISASI) and Royal Aeronautical Society (Pakistan Division) are co-hosting a seminar on 'Aviation Safety in Pakistan', sponsored by Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) today (July 10, 2009) in Multan.
According to a PIA spokesman here on Thursday, PIA Managing Director Captain Mohammad Aijaz Haroon will be the chief guest on the occasion. The seminar is expected to be attended by representatives of civil society, city notables, traders, business community of Multan, and delegates from airlines and general aviation organizations.
Source: www.brecorder.com
Govt Sitting On Multan Fokker Crash Report
By Zulqernain Tahir
LAHORE, July 9: The federal government has yet to make the Multan Fokker crash report public, three years after the tragic incident.
A Civil Aviation Authority official informed Dawn on Thursday that it had submitted the investigation report to the government and it was up to it to make it public. "The authority on its own cannot reveal anything in this regard," the official said.
As many as 41 passengers, including two judges of the Lahore High Court, a former principal of the King Edward Medical College and four crew members, lost their lives when the Lahore-bound Fokker (F-27) crashed soon after its take-off from the Multan airport on July 10, 2006.
A three-member team comprising Air Commodore Junaid Amin (head), Wing Commodore Nasim Ahmed and PIA's captain Dara Shah Nawaz had conducted the probe with the help of experts from the US, the UK, France, Germany and Netherlands.
Under the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) rules, it is mandatory for the CAA to make public the findings of the investigation into any aircraft crash.
The federal government even did not bother to share the investigation report with the countries it had sought help from in the process. The ICAO rules also require a member country to formally submit the findings of a plane crash probe to the other members it takes on board during investigation process.
Following the accident, the government had grounded the Fokker fleet.
According to a source in the authority, the ill-fated aircraft F-27, before starting its journey from Islamabad airport, had developed faults in its engine and radio instruments, which delayed its journey to Lahore by 40 minutes. "The pilot, Capt Hamid Qurehi, had lodged a complaint in this regard but to no avail," he said.
A fact-finding committee of High Court Bar Association, Multan, had said the aircraft, soon after its take-off (Lahore to Multan), got de-tracked for about 25 miles towards the eastern side of the Pakistani border due to flawed navigation system.The fact of plane's losing direction was brought to the pilot's knowledge, who responded that he had complained about the navigation system and other defects in the aircraft repeatedly but no body cared to remove them.
The source said the record proved that Capt Qureshi was overworked and fatigued and he was called to fly the aircraft after the rest of only six hours. "This practice still goes on despite frequent protests by pilots. A senior PIA pilot has been recently censured for pointing out induction of overworked co-pilot in his crew," he said.
According to a senior CAA official, the crash was primarily the outcome of "human error". He said one of the two engines of the 42-year-old plane had stopped working at the time of take-off and the pilot could not timely pull up the landing gear within the altitude of 400 feet. The plane crashed within one minute and 12 seconds of take-off.
The aircraft was manufactured in 1964 and bought by PIA in 1979 after remaining operational for fifteen years. It had a recommended 28 years of life (non-extendable).
Source: DAWN
Three years later, Fokker crash inquiry still awaited
Friday, July 10, 2009
By Mazhar Tufail
ISLAMABAD: Today is the third anniversary of Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) Fokker F-27 crash, in which 45 persons, including 04 crew members and 41 passengers, were killed, but neither the government has presented the inquiry report to the public nor taken disciplinary action against any of the officials responsible for the tragedy.
The PIA Flight 688 had crashed on July 10, 2006, at 12 noon, minutes after taking off from Multan Airport for Lahore. The plane had reportedly suffered engine problems and hit an electric power line before crashing in a nearby field. The plane had broken up and caught fire. It was 160th loss of a Fokker F-27 in the world, 9th worst accident involving a Fokker F-27 in terms of life loss and 3rd worst accident in Pakistan aviation at that time.
The then government of Pervez Musharraf had ordered an inquiry into the incident and the political parties had had raised a lot of hue and cry demanding punishment to the persons responsible for the plane crash. The Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), which was in opposition at that time, had even gone to the extent of pinpointing the culprits and vowing to bring them to the court of justice.
Now the same PPP is in power, but, like many other forgotten promises this too has not been fulfilled. After the 2008 elections, the crash victims' relatives expected that justice would be dispensed as Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gilani was elected from Multan and is said to have even personally known some of the crash victims.
The kin of victims wrote many letters to the PM to bring to justice the culprits behind the tragic incident and some of them even went to top government functionaries after the elections. Two high court judges, two brigadiers of the Pakistan Army and the best neurosurgeon of the country were among the crash victims.
The kin of the victims had another very bright hope in the person of Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) stalwart who too was elected from Multan in 2002 elections, Makhdoom Javed Hashmi, as his close relatives had died in the crash. Hashmi was personally devastated to an extent that he was in jail but went to Multan on a two-day parole to attend the funeral.
When the PPP and PML-N formed a coalition government after the 2008 elections, the people of Multan had a great hope from the two very seasoned politicians from the two largest political parties of the country, but like many other national tragedies, nobody has so far been punished for being responsible for the plane crash nor the investigation report has been made public.
A lot was written about many scenarios engulfing the crash and all possible scapegoats were desperately looked for, but thanks to the media, which was highly alive to the issue, such designs could not succeed.
This correspondent tried to contact Prime Minister Gilani for comments but could not succeed. Similarly, MNA Javed Hashmi is currently in the United States and could not be contacted despite repeated efforts.
When contacted, Sultan Hassan, PIA director public relations, said that heirs of all the Fokker crash victims have been paid insurance claims at the rate of Rs2 million per passenger except those of seven passengers. He said that according to the aviation rules, the PIA was liable to pay Rs0.5 million per passenger, but an amount of Rs2 million was paid to the heirs of the Fokker crash victims as a special case.
"The heirs of seven passengers developed disputes among themselves and went to the court so they have not been paid the insurance claim," he said. "They, too, will be paid but only after a court decision as to who are legitimate heirs," he added.
When contacted by The News, a senior official of the Ministry of Defence said, on condition of anonymity, that a report prepared by the Safety Investigation Board of the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) was sent to the ministry and was sent back by the ministry after vetting. He said that according to the report, the incident had occurred because of a technical fault.
Source: The News
Fokker crash inquiry report hitherto unaccounted for
Friday, July 10, 2009
MULTAN: The inquiry report of Fokker plane crash in Multan has yet to be publicized despite passing three years.
Forty-five people including crewmembers onboard when the plane crashed at Multan Airport right after the take off. All passengers and crewmembers killed in the incident. But so far, no official report has been released so far for the public and no action has been taken against those responsible for the crash.
Source: The News